This review may contain spoilers
Dark Twists and Sweet Treats: Exploring the Dark Realities of High School in High Cookie.
This show was an absolute roller coaster from start to finish, a fast paced dark thriller that consistently keeps you on the edge of your seat.Every character was intricately twisted. The show started with the simple, naive FL Choi Sooyoung, but as it progressed her character's layers peeled off one by one.
ML Hosu presented another complex character rarely seen in recent dramas with a painful backstory and compelling reasons for his actions, albeit criminal.
Filled with twists and turns the show delves into the stressful lives of high schoolers and explores how cookies serve as a means to fulfill their inner dreams.
In terms of romance, there wasnt much but I loved the scenes creators gave us of Lee Eunsoo & Jin Woo. They were simply a treat to watch. However, given the dark thriller theme romantic elements were understandably limited.
On the downside there were many unrealistic scenarios like police investigations, how Sooyoung got admission to school, etc. Additionally the production quality could have been much better. But what mattered to me is how much I enjoyed this show and from that point of view it was an absolute treat to watch.
The acting of each cast member was commendable. Nam Jihyun, Choi Hyunwook, Seo Bum June, Kim Mu Yeol, Jung Dabin and others delivered standout performances.
Spoiler: The ending was tragically fitting for the show. Due to FL's greed many students including Jinwoo & Hosu, met their tragic demise. Minyoung took on her sister's life, working part time, while Sooyoung disappeared from the world, going into hiding to make cookies.
In conclusion, I will recommend this show to every thriller lover who enjoys watching thrillers with high school settings and a gripping storyline.
Was this review helpful to you?
─ the twist of adult child.
Started this drama without any prior knowledge about the plot or the full cast. So, there weren't any expectations but I was glad to find this twisted and psychological approach to this kind theme. The conflict between desperation and greed was nicely written.From the beginning, the sisters and chef reminded me of children that are forced to become adults. Neither managed to grasp freedom and instead followed a way that offered them dream like escape. At some point, you find yourself feeling bad for them, another time you question their morals and greed. Even at the ending scene, you still witness the twist in their ordinary looking lives, which I think was quite unique to see.
While the story had its ups and downs, sometimes left you looking for more and sometimes felt draggy, the cast did awesome job at their characters. Especially Nam Jihyun and Choi Hyunwook rightfully owned the spotlight as they portrayed desperate people that did not hesitate to turn bad when it comes to "being able to live."
Overall, it was a nice watch that delivered specific messages successfully.
link to edits : https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLI-LyvxxdMxBiq-NfStjWeJ-HBXaMzBcV&si=06NZ4vCYhhrRcZgj
Was this review helpful to you?
A decent thriller that shows what greed does to people
I found it from out of no where , literally no buzz, no proper subs yet found it decent and enjoyed watching it.If you compare it to a book you read the first half and found it interesting , You turn the page and every character feels new and different in the second half . The story pace is quick and the plot twist's are new and refreshing.
It is basically about cookie addicts , family bonding and betrayal upon betrayal. The only strong bond i found in this is family bond the rest is all betrayal and greed.
The characters are twisted and dark , you can literally trust noooo one in the drama.
This is basically one of those dramas where they do something bad and unethical and blame it on the past traumas , helpless situation and greed to become rich. By in the end as one of the characters says " all of it is just an excuse".
In the end, do i hate any of them , definetly NO. Yet i cannot overlook the little yet obvious plot holes here. They show a person has full power and is invincible yet the next second they show the same person is vulnerable and weak.
Moral of the story :-
If you expose your weakness , vulture like humans will not think even a second to take advantage of it and greed can get you to do anything and ur mind will probably give you a concinving and reasonable answer to it.
I would say the hero here is ... not Soo Young... not Ho so, not seong pil, not minyoung BUT " The cookie"
If you are into mini thriller series who thinks little plotholes are bearable and enjoys excellent actor , you can give this a try. Every episode has something new at times dumb things for you.
Was this review helpful to you?
"거짓말은 거짓말로 막는 거야".
?The 8th episode is when I hoped this burnt cookie flips over and shows us its colorful glazing. Alas! This webdrama seems to arise more questions than answers, and by the middle you don't care enough to unravel them. By "questions" I mean it throws random interactions, circumstances and accidents at the viewer and expects you to edit the drama in your head by yourself. The plot is atrociously incoherent and unconscious. I have never met such disrespectful and humiliating for its viewers drama. Not even Seven First Kisses can compete.Who want what? Who does what? Why? Why aren't all the students at that school high on those cookies? Or why are they? Doesn't that "application coach" have better things to do? Why does everyone hate everyone at school? Did you really think I was gonna believe that idiotic ending? Did you really think I was gonna empathize with all those detestable characters? What do you think I am?
?The reason I'm so furious about this webdrama is that such good actors as Choi Hyeon Wook (right after the splendid Twinkling Watermelon), Jeong Da Bin and Nam Ji Hyeon ended up in the hands of a screenwriter who lacks any emotional intelligence whatsoever. The presence of the director of Youth of May didn't help either.
Undoubtedly, there are many people who thoroughly enjoyed the story, but I took it very personal, as you can see. I just can't battle the detestation that kept arising in me with each episode. I gotta admit, it's harder to explain why a movie is bad than to tell how much you love it. It's still the ground to explore for me.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Mixed feelings on this drama…
When thinking of how I could describe this drama in one sentence, all I could think about is how difficult and confusing it was to formulate a sentence. It a really good drama in the middle. Both the beginning and end are harder to watch to me. Not because of the content, but because of the atmosphere and character choices.For me personally what made the beginning and end hard to watch was Choi Min Young, I don’t know if her character was meant to be so frustrating. But every time she was present, I found myself uninterested in the way she would go about things and her character development. That’s why for me the middle is the best part, her not being there drove the story even more, but also allowed the other characters to do things freely without her holding them back. An example of what made me frustrated, and also showed that she was kind of a hindrance to the story was when she first wakes up from being in a coma she starts pulling strings, as if she has been there the whole time. She seemed like a very controlling character that had no reason to be as controlling as she was. Maybe that’s just her personality and she’s very strong headed but for her to wake up and tell her sister “we’re gonna go back to normal” “you can’t do this anymore” etc.. was something that made her not only unlikable, but made the drama harder to watch.
Besides CMY making the drama herder to watch, how slow, some of the characters were in making fast paced decisions made me disconnect from the story that was being told. I think for the content and situations that they were in a lot of the time you had to be really fast at what you’re going to do next otherwise they would be repercussions. Yoo Seong Pil for instant did this a lot and maybe because he is a police officer you could tell those times where he would pause and think everything out. But he would do that during scenes in which you can’t pause. You could say that he’s acting this way because of the drugs, but those are also drugs that enhance thinking so it’s very weird of him to take so much time to do something. Like when Seo Ho Su’s mom was having a seizure I couldn’t tell if he was being strategic in not helping her or just froze in fright. Either way from what we know of him he’s a smart cunning person you would think that in that situation he would be on top of things without hesitation.
Despite of the characters lacking storylines, my favorite part of the drama was in the high school. There’s a lot that Choi Soo Young could work with, and I really enjoyed her dynamic with Song Jin Woo. Those two characters were the highlight of the whole drama for me. I liked how she could be funny at times with him and he would be serious but also kinda let his guard down. If drama has a season two I would love to see how the characters develop more because there was a lot of them that needed background stories because I couldn’t understand why they did what they did or how they got to where they are.
✧Overall the dramas is pretty good, if you have time to watch it, please do so. But it’s also not a drama that is a must watch. My opinion the best episodes are 4-16 so if you don’t mind how the drama kinda drags in the other seven episodes, then give it a watch. I think this drama would improve with a season two that explains why the characters are who they are. In the end it was a harder drama to finish, but at least I was able to complete it.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Loved that Kdrama
I’ve watch that kdrama because of the cast and I was not disappointed, my fav actor in the cast is Choi HyunWook I was wondering why he would choose a role like Seo Hosu that at first but I understood why at ep9I really loved that character as well as Choi Minyoung and Choi Sooyoung
I think the story itself and the idea of Cookie is amazing, I loved the plot twist at ep9 and ep19/20 about Seo Hosu, what he did and what happens to him as well as what happen the Sooyoung, and finally I hope for a season 2 because of the last scene with Minyoung
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Not your typical ending
Welll my bad for expecting it gonna finished wiith bright ending end with friendship values. You can't overlook the fact no matter how good reasons/purposes the characters have, they all are actually criminals, no difference with drug seller irl. I'm not saying the deserves those ending but they don't deserve happy ending neither. Overall as someone who fond to thriller/crime and action, I love it. It exceed my expectation, not expecting the twist and ending though. The 'expect the unexpected' in this is hardOn characters? Hosoo's whole story build up is the most painful sad, I cried. But again, he is the backbone to all of these. Jinwoo. My fav character, rooting for him for no reason and devastated when he no longer live... The actor is good expressing using his eyes. Would love to see more eloboration on his relationship and Hosoo. Sooyoung/Eunsol is a strong character indeed, just lost in the end which cause a hugeeee damage
Was this review helpful to you?
Dropping it because the subs are missing
PS. My ratings here are random since I couldn't post a review without them.I read the comments and seeing two types of ppl : those who struggle finishing eventho it started off well and those who, as well as I, want to make their own opinion on it but can't because of how weird the subs are on streaming sites to the point I'm thinking abt dropping the series since the subtitles are weird asf and incoherent... Characters all had their names written in chinese when here you could clearly tell their names are supposed to be korean ? to be more precise about the problem.
Having the subs being off makes the series understanding hard for us since nothing is coherent and relevant ?. This just destroyed the ratings of the series and even its chance to be well-known
Was this review helpful to you?
Bon mais pas inoubliable
J'étais très curieuse à l'idée de découvrir cette série.... Du coup, j'ai été un peu déçue.Le scénario était prometteur, les personnages intéressants, mais ça n'a pas duré toute la série. Ça dérape à un moment.
En général, j'aime beaucoup les histoire ou les personnages mutent (que ce soit dans leur tête ou dans leur corps). Mais là, c'est brouillon, voir incohérent. Peut-être que ces changements auraient mérités un ou deux épisodes de plus. Du coup, j'ai perdu l'attachement que j'avais pour les personnages au début.
D'ailleurs, un autre regret, c'est justement la place des personnages secondaires. Certains étaient prometteurs et je m'attendais plus ou moins à les voir prendre de l'ampleur ; et puis, non, ils restent justes secondaires. Au point qu'ils n'ont plus d'intérêt pour le scénario (on se demande même parfois pourquoi ils sont encore dans les épisodes). C'est vraiment dommage.
Dans les derniers épisodes, j'ai vraiment trouvé que le scénario devenait poussif (je me suis même demandé s'il n'y avait pas eut un changement de scénariste en cours de route).
Heureusement, les acteurs eux, sont au top : c'est bien jouer.
Bref, j'ai passé un bon moment à visionner cette série, mais je ne regarderais sans doute pas une seconde fois.
Was this review helpful to you?
